How is ROA calculated?
For a manufacturer earning ₹615 crore on ₹6,200 crore of assets, the return is 9.9%.
Worked example: Summit Toolworks vs Cascade Machine: why plain ROA misleads (synthetic, US)
Two synthetic US machine-tool makers with the identical operating business (revenue $2,000m, EBIT $300m, average total assets $2,000m, tax 25%) financed differently. Summit Toolworks is all-equity, and Cascade Machine carries $800m of debt at 6%. Watch what each return measure says about two firms that are, at the operating level, twins.
| $m | Summit (no debt) | Cascade (debt $800 @ 6%) |
|---|---|---|
| EBIT | 300 | 300 |
| − Interest | 0 | 48 |
| EBT | 300 | 252 |
| − Tax (25%) | 75 | 63 |
| Net income | 225 | 189 |
| Average total assets | 2,000 | 2,000 |
| Average equity | 2,000 | 1,200 |
| Plain ROA = NI ÷ assets | 11.25% | 9.45% |
| Adjusted ROA = (NI + int×(1−t)) ÷ assets | 11.25% | 11.25% |
| Operating ROA = EBIT ÷ assets | 15.0% | 15.0% |
| ROE = NI ÷ equity | 11.25% | 15.75% |
Step 1: the plain-ROA lie. Plain ROA rates Summit (11.25%) a better asset user than Cascade (9.45%), yet the two run the same assets to the same $300m of EBIT. The gap is pure capital structure. Plain ROA puts an after-interest profit over assets that debt helped finance, so it docks Cascade for borrowing. That's the inconsistency behind convention 4 in 4.3.
Step 2: repair it two ways. Add back Cascade's after-tax interest: (189 + 48 × 0.75) ÷ 2,000 = (189 + 36) ÷ 2,000 = 11.25%, now equal to Summit. Or ignore financing and tax altogether: operating ROA = 300 ÷ 2,000 = 15.0% for both. The twins are revealed as twins.
Step 3: read the ROE, and the spread. ROE is supposed to reflect financing, and it does. Cascade's 15.75% beats Summit's 11.25% because the borrowed $800m works at an after-tax operating return of 11.25% while costing only 4.5% after tax. That 6.75-point spread lands on a thinner equity base. The leverage identity confirms it: 11.25 + (11.25 − 4.5) × (800 ÷ 1,200) = 15.75%. So use plain ROA only for one company's own time series. To rank two companies with different debt, use adjusted or operating ROA. And the distance between a firm's adjusted ROA and its ROE is its leverage story, told at a glance.
Advertisements
What does a high or low ROA mean?
Return on assets comes into its own for banks, where the balance sheet is the business. For an Indian bank, a return on assets above 1% is respectable and above 1.5% is strong. Those lines are a local working range and not a law of banking: in Japan and much of Europe the whole distribution is lower, and a bank there can be soundly run at levels that would look weak here. For a software company the same numbers would be dismal, so the ratio is only ever compared within a sector, and only ever within a market.
For industrials, return on capital employed usually beats it.